A.V. Opinions: 20 Horror movies that are better than their low Rotten Tomatoes scores
Horror movies are often divisive—what entertains one person might bore another. But some movies in this genre get an unfairly low rating, especially on Rotten Tomatoes. Below, I’ve compiled 20 horror movies that I think deserve a better look despite their low Rotten Tomatoes scores. For this list, each movie had to score 59% or lower. Grab some popcorn, turn off the lights, and dive into these underrated gems.
Intruder (1989)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: N/A
A slasher set in a grocery store, directed by Sam Raimi’s high school buddy Scott Spiegel. This movie combines creative kills and campy vibes. If you're into the Evil Dead style of off-the-wall camera work, this is a fun ride. You can tell this was made by the guys who brought us Evil Dead.
Idle Hands (1999)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 16%
A horror-comedy that mixes stoner humor with slasher elements, this movie tells the story of a teenager whose hand becomes possessed. Its unique premise and blend of genres make it an underrated classic that has garnered a loyal fanbase. This is one of the last great '90s horror movies. It's as if they took the Evil Dead's possessed hand concept and expanded it into a full-length movie.
House of 1000 Corpses (2003)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 22%
Rob Zombie's directorial debut is a wild ride through the twisted mind of the Firefly family. While it was criticized for its chaotic style and violence, it has since become a cult classic. Its unique blend of horror, humor, and creepy visuals creates a memorable experience that celebrates the genre. I personally think House of 1000 Corpses is the best modern Grindhouse movie, and I even believe it surpasses the film that inspired it, the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre. I know that's considered blasphemy, but I think it's true.
The Island of Dr. Moreau (1997)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 22%
Beneath its troubled production lies a uniquely unhinged masterpiece. Marlon Brando and Val Kilmer's unorthodox performances add to the movie's unsettling allure, making for an unforgettable viewing experience. Despite its flaws, I love every chaotic minute of this mesmerizing mess. The Island of Dr. Moreau is a trainwreck that's impossible to look away from.
As Above, So Below (2014)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 28%
Set in the catacombs beneath Paris, where the filmmakers remarkably obtained permission to shoot, this found-footage flick combines historical intrigue with supernatural elements. Its creative setting and claustrophobic atmosphere provide an unnerving experience, making it an underrated entry in the found-footage genre.
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 37%
I may face backlash for this, but I believe this remake surpasses the original in every way. Seriously. The opening scene is more impactful, annoying characters are eliminated, the kills are more intense, and R. Lee Ermey's addition as a member of the Sawyer family elevates the material. His performance is even more terrifying than Leatherface. This movie was unfairly maligned due to being a remake of a horror classic. I think it deserves reevaluation alongside the original.
Scarecrows (1988)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 42%
This lesser-known slasher flick follows a group of thieves who encounter terrifying, sentient scarecrows. Its unique premise and practical effects create a chilling atmosphere deserving of more recognition. Although dated, this movie's concept is compelling. Imagine a crew pulling off a heist, hiding out in an abandoned farmhouse surrounded by cornfields, and scarecrows coming to life. I love this original horror/heist idea! Scarecrows needs to be remade for modern audiences.
Fade to Black (1980)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 42%
This psychological horror flick follows a disturbed movie fanatic who becomes a killer. Its commentary on fandom and identity offers depth often missing from the genre. Fade to Black is a horror movie about horror movies and is a must-watch for every fan. The finale's iconic setting at the legendary Grauman's Chinese Theatre in Los Angeles adds to its haunting conclusion.
Tusk (2014)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 46%
Kevin Smith's body horror flick about a podcaster transformed into a walrus may sound bizarre, but it's a unique exploration of obsession. Its dark humor and unpredictable storyline make it a standout, despite mixed reviews from critics. Michael Parks delivers a twisted, Looney Tunes-esque performance that's an absolute must-watch. The walrus fight scene alone is worth the price of admission. Tusk is severely underrated.
Cooties (2014)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 46%
This horror-comedy about a zombie outbreak in an elementary school combines laughs with scares, featuring a stellar cast including Elijah Wood and Rainn Wilson. Its playful take on the genre makes it a hidden gem. This movie is like a love letter to George A. Romero. The performances are hilarious, and watching adults kill zombie kids is incredibly entertaining. I'm hoping we someday get a "Road Trip Cooties" streaming series where zombie kids are a global threat. Additionally, this movie will make you think twice about eating chicken nuggets.
Clown (2014)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 48%
Clown is a story about a father who turns into a demonic clown after donning a cursed suit. This is from director Jon Watts, of the MCU Spider-Man trilogy. Not only is this a great, underrated movie with excellent body horror, but the behind-the-scenes story of how it got made is worth a Google. Watts made a fake trailer saying it was from horror icon Eli Roth. Roth saw the trailer and gave Watts a shot. Now Watts is a Marvel director and is known for one of Marvel's biggest blockbuster franchises. Highly recommended!
Saw (2004)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 50%
You're kidding me, no way this is Rotten! Look, I'm not necessarily a fan of torture porn, but this first movie is a classic that spawned a franchise still going strong today. It boasts one of the best modern plot twists and endings in any horror film. Although often criticized for its graphic violence and convoluted plot, the film revolutionized the horror genre, making it a game-changer.
Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 50%
This installment in the Halloween franchise strays from the Michael Myers formula, focusing instead on a creepy conspiracy involving an evil corporation, masks, and Halloween. While fans were initially disappointed, it has gained a cult following for its originality and eerie atmosphere. This might be my favorite Halloween movie. It's a clever commentary on consumerism, and overall, it's an entertaining holiday flick, anchored by Tom “Thrill Me” Atkins.
The Munsters (2022)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 54%
Rob Zombie's The Munsters received mixed reviews, but it's a love letter to the show, with Zombie's heart and soul evident in every frame. The movies colorful visuals and humor resonated with me. However, a black-and-white re-release would likely enhance its critical reception, potentially boosting reviews to 60-70%. I believe this movie is unfairly judged. I love every performance and hope someday we'll get a sequel.
Feast (2005)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 55%
Feast is a gory ride that showcases a group of people fighting for survival against monstrous creatures. This movie is a fun, horror-filled siege movie. I like my horror with buckets of blood, gross-outs, but mainly fun, and this movie delivers on all fronts. Feast 2 is similarly batshit crazy and worth a watch.
JeruZalem (2015)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 56%
Set in Jerusalem during a demon-fueled apocalypse, this found-footage film offers a fresh take on the genre, blending supernatural elements with a unique setting. Its captivating premise and execution make it an underrated gem. Filming in the holy city must have been challenging due to all the legal red tape. I hope we get a sequel exploring different perspectives, such as military or religious leaders experiencing the apocalypse. Check it out.
Monster Squad (1987)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 56%
My son adores this cult classic, and its charm has rubbed off on me. As one of his favorite films, I've had the pleasure of rediscovering its magic through his eyes. The Monster Squad is an ideal gateway to the horror genre, especially for young viewers. Its blend of adventure, humor, and spooky fun has captivated audiences for generations. Plus, who can forget the iconic line: "The Wolfman’s got nards!"
Bad Milo (2013)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 58%
This hidden gem is a fun horror-comedy about a man with a demon living in his butt, offering a unique blend of humor and horror. Although critics were divided, its absurd premise and quirky execution have earned it a dedicated following. Come on, a butt demon emerging to kill people? Sold! What more could you ask for?
Frankenstein’s Army (2013)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 58%
This found-footage horror movie follows Russian soldiers discovering an abandoned location housing a descendant of Dr. Frankenstein, who created an army of undead soldiers for Hitler. The practical effects are entertaining, boasting impressive designs that blend Call of Duty, Wolfenstein, Bioshock and steampunk elements with the classic horror of Frankenstein. It's a fun them park ride of a movie.
My Bloody Valentine (1981)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 58%
My Bloody Valentine is a 1981 Canadian slasher film, praised by Quentin Tarantino as one of his favorites. The movie tells the story of a killer who returns to a small mining town on Valentine's Day to murder those celebrating the holiday. It's a fun, old-school slasher. If you're looking for a hidden gem, grab a box of Valentine's Day candies, sit back, and EAT YOUR HEART OUT!
So there you have it. These movies might not be "critically acclaimed," but they’ve earned their place in horror history. Whether it’s inventive kills, quirky humor, or sheer originality, each of these movies deserves a second chance. Ready for a marathon?
-Brad McBoom